Cristy's Pizza Lancaster West Menu
Welcome to Cristy's Pizza Lancaster West, a beloved local gem nestled at 914 Pierce Ave, Lancaster, OH. This pizzeria captivates with its exceptional menu, where every dish is a celebration of flavor and quality.
Customers rave about the friendly service and wide selection, from classic large pepperoni pizzas to unique offerings like cauliflower crust and pulled pork pizza. The vegetarian-friendly chef salad has also garnered praise for its delightful toppings, making it a hit among health-conscious patrons.
Located conveniently for locals and visitors alike, Cristy's stands out not only for its delicious food but also for its welcoming management. Each visit promises a memorable experience, whether you’re enjoying their hearty pizzas or exploring the fresh salads.
- Address: 914 Pierce Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130
- Phone: +1 740-653-8106
Whether you're a long-time fan or a first-time visitor, Cristy’s Pizza Lancaster West is sure to become your favorite pizza destination!
Drinks
Diet Coke
20oz
Sprite
20oz
Dasani Water
Enhanced with a proprietary blend of minerals to give it the clean, fresh taste you want from water.
Coca-Cola
20oz
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, tomato, cucumber, Parmesan & croutons.
Bigg House Salad
Feeds 8-10 -- Lettuce, Tomato ,Provolone and Bacon.
Salad Your Way
Layer a bed of fresh chopped mixed greens with your choice of meats, cheeses & veggies.
Large House Salad
A side for 2 or a meal for 1 - Fresh mixed greens with tomato, bacon & provolone.
Taco Salad
Taco beef,tomato,onion,black olive,jalapeno,provolone & cheddar cheese,
Small House Salad
Feeds 1--Fresh mixed greens with tomato,bacon & provolone.
Chef Salad
Loaded with pepperoni, ham, provolone, mushroom, tomato, green pepper, onion, green olive, hot pepper & croutons.
Garden Fresh Salads
Original Pizzas
New York Pepperoni
Triangle cut slices with pepperoni over provolone & creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce brushed dough. “Fuggetaboutit” nobody does it better.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Creamy ranch dressing,grilled chicken & three cheese blend topped with chives & Choose Your Heat: Mild,Medium,or Hot!
Large New York Pepperoni
Triangle cut slices with pepperoni over provolone & housemade creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce brushed dough. “Fuggedaboutit” nobody does it better.
The Goliath
DOUBLE PEPPERONI & EXTRA CHEESE. Two thick layers of provolone layered completely with pepperoni.
The Islander
ALOHA! Hickory-smoked ham, pineapple, cinnamon & provolone.
Veggie
Tomato,mushroom,onion,green pepper,hot pepper,green olive,black olive & provolone.
Four Cheese
A gooey combination of four of our favorite cheeses. We've layered the highest quality provolone, mozzarella, cheddar and Parmesan and baked it atop our fresh dough to create a cheesy, mouthwatering masterpiece.
Hot Sauce
Honey Mustard
Lite Italian Dressing
Italian Dressing
French Dressing
Bleu Cheese
Sweet & Tangy Tomato Sauce
Ranch Dressing
Miracle Whip
Creamy Garlic Butter
Fat Free Ranch Dressing
BBQ Sauce
Sauce
Extras
Side Jalapeño Peppers
Parmesan Cheese Pack
Side Yellow Banana Peppers
Mild banana pepper rings.
Red Pepper Seed Pack
Cristy's Classic
A customer favorite with ham, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom, hot pepper & provolone.
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Creamy Garlic Butter sauce,sliced sirloin steak,green pepper,mushroom,onion,extra provolone & extra cheddar cheese.
Bigg Meat
The name speaks for itself when you load up with salami, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, & provolone to keep it all together. Better grab a friend (or five) for this one.
The Italian Pizza
Sweet & tangy tomato sauce, pepperoni, salami, ham, hot pepper, onion & provolone topped with our Cristy's Italian spice blend.
Taco Pizza
Taco beef,onion,black olive,three cheese blend & jalapeno topped with tomato & lettuce with a side of sour cream.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Creamy ranch dressing, grilled chicken, bacon, tomato, provolone & cheddar.
Loaded Pizzas
House-Made Calzones
Cristy's Classic
Provolone, ham, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom & hot pepper. Better use a knife & fork, it gets messy.
Create-Your-Own Calzone
A custom made calzone just for you. Additional Fillings for an additional charge.
Veggie
Tomato, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, green olives, black olives, and provolone
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken, bacon, tomato, provolone & cheddar with creamy ranch dressing.
Bigg Meat
Believe it or not, we found a way to load it with salami, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham & provolone.
Taco Calzone
Taco beef,tomato,onion,black olive,jalapeno,provolone & cheddar cheese.
The Islander
Provolone, ham and pineapple.
Peanut Butter Crispy Bar
For a limited time,$1 from each bar will be donated to your Local Food Bank
White Chunk Macadamia Cookie
A Best Made all-American White Chunk Macadamia classic cookie to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Big Brookie
Our Bigg 9 Inch Brookie,Baked and Served warm. A perfect blend of Decadent Fudgy Brownie and Chocolate Chip Cookie.
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
A decadent fudgy brownie loaded with heavenly chocolate chips.
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
A Best Made All-American Chocolate Chunk cookie to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Chocolate Chip M&M Cookie
A Best Made all-American Chocolate Chip M&M classic cookie to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Desserts
Appetizers
Pepperoni Nibblerz (10 Pieces)
Single bites of pepperoni pizza all rolled up, slathered with creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce. Served with sweet & tangy tomato or creamy Parmesan garlic butter.
Cristy's Famous Cheesy Breadstix
Is it the provolone? Our creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce? Or could it be the sweet & tangy tomato dipping sauce? We're not sure what folks love the most, we just know they love 'em.
Chicken Wings
Oven-baked plain and rolled in your choice of BBQ,Hot,Medium,or Mild.
Cristy's Famous Large Cheesy Breadstix
Is it the premium provolone? Our house made creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce? Or could it be the tangy tomato dipping sauce? We're not sure what folks love the most,we just know they love ‘em. Great to share!.
Four Cheese Garlic Bread
An Italian loaf with creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce then topped with provolone, cheddar, Parmesan & mozzarella with a side of sweet & tangy tomato sauce.
Cluckers
1/2 Pound Baked Boneless Chicken Nuggets with choice of dipping sauce.
Cheese Nibblerz (10 Pieces)
Single bites of cheese pizza all rolled up, slathered with creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce. Served with sweet & tangy tomato or creamy Parmesan garlic butter.
The Italian Sub
Provolone, salami, ham, pepperoni, hot pepper, onion, lettuce, tomato & side of Italian dressing.
Turkey Bacon Club Sub
Join the club with oven-roasted turkey,crispy bacon,ham,provolone,lettuce,tomato,and side of Miracle Whip
Turkey Sub
Keep it simple with oven-roasted turkey,provolone,lettuce,tomato,and side of Miracle Whip
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Creamy ranch dressing, grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, provolone & cheddar.
Pizza Sub
Our delicious pepperoni pizza in sandwich form.
Meatball Sub
100% beef meatballs in sweet & tangy tomato sauce covered with provolone.
Philly Cheese Steak Sub
Sliced sirloin,green pepper,onion,mushroom,lettuce,tomato,provolone,cheddar cheese & choice of A.1. or Miracle Whip on the side.
Sirloin Steak Sub
Sliced sirloin steak,lettuce,tomato,provolone & choice of A.1. or Miracle Whip on the side,
Veggie Sub
Provolone, lettuce, tomato, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, green olive, black olive & side of Italian dressing.
Ham & Cheese Sub
An American classic with ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato & side of Italian dressing.
Chicken Sub
Grilled chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato & choice of Miracle Whip or honey mustard on the side.
Oven-Baked Subs
Build-Your-Own Pizza
Build Your Own X Large Pizza
A custom made pizza just for you. Start with a Provolone cheese pizza and add all your favorite toppings!
Build Your Own Small
A custom made pizza just for you. Start with a Provolone cheese pizza and add all your favorite toppings!
Build Your Own Medium Pizza
A custom made pizza just for you. Start with a Provolone cheese pizza and add all your favorite toppings!
Build Your Own Small Cauliflower Crust Pizza
A custom made pizza just for you. Start with a Provolone cheese pizza and add all your favorite toppings! Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Build Your Own Personal
A custom made pizza just for you. Start with a Provolone cheese pizza and add all your favorite toppings!
Build Your Own Large Pizza
A custom made pizza just for you. Start with a Provolone cheese pizza and add all your favorite toppings!
Cauliflower Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Creamy Garlic Butter sauce,sliced sirloin steak,green peppers,mushrooms,onions,extra provolone and extra cheddar cheese on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower New York Pepperoni
Triangle cut slices with pepperoni over provolone & creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce brushed cauliflower dough. “Fuggetaboutit” nobody does it better. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Cheesy Breadstix
Creamy garlic butter sauce and Provolone cheese on cauliflower dough with a side of tomato sauce. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower BiggMeat
The name speaks for itself when you load up with salami,pepperoni,sausage,bacon,ham,and provolone on cauliflower dough to keep it all together. Better grab a friend (or five) for this one. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Classic
A customer favorite with ham,pepperoni,sausage,onion,green pepper,mushroom,hot pepper & provolone on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Italian
Sweet & tangy tomato sauce,pepperoni,salami,ham,hot pepper,onion & provolone topped with our Cristy’s Italian spice blend on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Taco Pizza
Seasoned ground beef, onion, black olive, cheese blend of provolone, mozzarella, & cheddar, tomato & jalapeno peppers baked on. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower The Islander
ALOHA! Hickory-smoked ham, pineapple, cinnamon & provolone on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Veggie
Tomato,mushroom,onion,green pepper,hot pepper,green olive,black olive & provolone on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Four Cheese
A gooey combination of four of our favorite cheeses. We've layered the highest quality provolone, mozzarella, cheddar and Parmesan and baked it atop our cauliflower dough to create a cheesy, mouthwatering masterpiece. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower The Goliath
DOUBLE PEPPERONI & EXTRA CHEESE. Two thick layers of provolone layered completely with pepperoni on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower BBQ Pulled Pork Pizza
BBQ Pulled Pork is BACK FOR A LIMITED TIME! Original sweet & tangy tomato sauce,BBQ sauce,3 cheese blend,smoked pulled pork & applewood smoked bacon. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
Cauliflower Chicken Bacon Ranch
Creamy ranch dressing,grilled chicken,bacon,tomato,provolone & cheddar on cauliflower dough. Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.